WBW ’12: Why Such Bad Medical Advice?

I’ve been fortunate in my breastfeeding journey to not only have great support from friends, family and La Leche League (LLL,) but I’ve also had the experience of having great physicians who have not only been supportive of breastfeeding, but also knowledgeable.

This is why I find it so bothersome and disconcerting when I hear of moms that hear inaccurate, if not down-right BAD, advice regarding breastfeeding. I decided to ask varying groups of women, of all ages, what the worst advice regarding breastfeeding they had personally heard. Here’s the best of the worst (or should that be worst of the worst?) Either way:

  • That everything was OK, baby was supposed to be that angry, no need to look at latch. 5 days later baby hospitalized…dehydrated and literally close to death. Mommas should trust their instinct.
  • my milk is poison to my baby and i need to switch my baby to formula immediately
  • A pediatric resident told me that there is no health organzation in the world that recommends nursing after 12 months.
  • To put my twins on the same feeding schedule. LOL Yeah, right! I nursed when they were hungy, which meant I sat around nursing all the time in those early weeks, but that was a good thing! :)
  • Don’t wake him to nurse (said of a five and a half pound premature baby).
  • “he’s manipulating you with the breast!” regarding demand feedings. Ugh!!!!
  • I was told to wean when I had mastitis because my baby was one and could have cows milk
  • That my tired newborn was able to “drain the breast” in 10 minutes, so I should switch sides after 10 minutes at every feeding. And to keep at the 10 minute per side rule even when oversupply and overactive let-down became an issue…Feeding my 4 month old rice cereal “if she seems hungry” after nursing comes in a close second for worst advice ever, though.
  • With my first, the ped told me she didn’t need to nurse at night after age six months.
  • That tongue and lips ties are harmless and don’t effect BFing
In my mind, breastfeeding falls into the same realm as discipline or sleep… it’s more of a parenting thing than a medical thing. But understandably, it would make sense to consult with a medical professional about lactation, as lactation is a function of the body. So why all of the bad info? What do medical professionals learn about breastfeeding?
I asked that question of our old family practitioner. She graduated medical school in 2004 and is an amazing wife, mother and physician. I knew that she wouldn’t skirt the issue and  here is her response (emphasis mine) :
For formal breastfeeding education I got 4 half days (3-4 hours) of shadowing an IBCLC on hospital rounds, rounding on postpartum moms when they are in hospital. This took place either my second or third year. The intern year is mostly inpatient rotations and I got no formal education on breastfeeding. Anything I learned, good or bad, came from the example of the nurses, upper level residents or attendings. Looking back I feel sad about some of the things that were “routine” on those rotations. For example, when we discharged women who had just had a baby from the L+D floor we were instructed to ask every woman what she wanted to do for contraception and we were especially encouraged to give women the Depo-Provera shot. I feel sad about this now for many reasons (especially because I don’t believe in contraception and I recently finally got the courage to stop prescribing) but related to breastfeeding I now know that this can irreversibly decrease a woman’s milk supply and I may have contributed to the lactation failure of some women.
When on pediatrics I was influenced by the lack of formal education about breastfeeding. From my involvement in the Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine I do know that there are pediatricians who have developed curricula for individual residency programs but residency education is really dependent on the individual residency. There is an outline of what has to be taught but how that is carried out is variable.
We are required to complete Continuing medical education  (CME) hours every year but the topic of the CME is up to the physician. So breastfeeding is completely optional. I really like dermatology so I often do conferences on derm, for example.
The horrid advice that you have heard given is unfortunately all too common and the studies on this have shown that this is because there is such a lack of education and that nurses and physicians rely on their own experiences (good or bad) to advise moms. (i.e., oh, I couldn’t make enough milk, its OK if you don’t make it). When I was working in the office setting as a resident I encountered a mom who was engorged. I could not have diagnosed her pain as such but I had already rotated with the IBCLC so I knew that I needed to call her for advice. Over the phone she told me how to advise the mother. That is the only breastfeeding issue I addressed during my entire 3 year residency. Everything I learned about breastfeeding I learned long after completing my residency, first by going to LLL meetings and then by seeking out L-CERP conferences.

So there you have it. She also attached a PDF statement from the Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine that I will put on the CCM Facebook page a little later. (Depending on when you are reading this, I might be on a plane en route to the midwest!) You can also check out more bad advice on the page as well! :)

The takeaway from this is, when looking for a “breastfeeding friendly” pediatrician or family practitioner you may want to consider asking the physician what type of breastfeeding training they have. Their answer may clue you in to the type of advice you may get if you run into any breastfeeding issues. And if you are ever in doubt… call your local LLL. Seriously.

______________________________________________________________

Coming up this week:

Tomorrow: Breastfeeding in the Bible

Monday: Modesty and Breastfeeding (Guest Post over at Imperfect Kate)

Tuesday: Avoiding Bottle-feeding guilt

 

 

Post to Twitter

NFP Awareness Week: Lactational Amenorrhea/ Postpartum Charting

When I asked for ideas for this week, quite a few ladies wanted to know more about Lactational Amenorrhea and Postpartum Charting. So, here we go!

 

Postpartum Charting

I contacted a pair of NFP (Billings and STM) teachers I know and asked them for their thoughts on Postpartum Charting. Here are their main things to consider.

As with the rest of this series, please understand that this is in no way a substitute for an NFP/FAM class and for instruction with a certified instructor.

  • It’s good to begin before your first menses. Some women don’t think they need to start charting until their menses returns, but it’s possible to ovulate prior to the first menses (although this is less likely if you are exclusively breastfeeding and <6 months post-partum, it is possible.) 
  • Some women like to begin charting again after lochia has finished. Others prefer to wait until they observe some signs of rising fertility, such as fertile-type mucus, before beginning.
  • When you’re making/charting mucus observations, be aware that if you observed soon after nursing the lubrication breastfeeding stimulates could be mistaken for fertile mucus.
  • Chart all bleeding, but not all bleeding is menses. There’s no scientific standard for determining the first menstrual bleed post-partum. As a rule of thumb, a menses should have days of medium or heavy bleeding, not just light bleeding or spotting, and it should have a crescendo-decrescendo pattern. But trumping the rule of thumb is whether the woman feels like it is her period or not. So just to stop and question yourself when noting bleeding. Does this feel like a period to me? If it does, the woman should start another chart. But if she feels it was just spotting (breakthrough bleeding) she can continue the current chart.
  • Post-partum charting requires patience and the charting equivalent of thick skin. Before the first ovulation, temps can be highly variable, but you should still see a clear sustained rise after the first ovulation. And about 1/3 of women may have mucus signs that don’t correlate so well with their hormonal fertility status, usually with lots of mucus caused by breastfeeding hormonal fluctuations. So it can help to work with an instructor to help distinguish details and interpretation if you’re unsure.
  • The first cycle after the return of menses is typically longer than usual, so requires more patience with abstinence, but usually has a shorter luteal phase.
  • As a STM instructor our clients don’t start a new chart postpartum until they confirm it’s true menses through a qualifying temp shift. They may start new charts for organization, labeling them Chart1, chart 1a, chart1b, etc but that’s all. 
  • After the first 56 days, postpartum, all bleeding is considered fertile until a temp shift is confirmed and legitimate AF is known.
  • A benefit of charting earlier vs waiting is that if you do have a basic infertile pattern (BIP) it’s easier to establish that early on vs once your hormones start fluctuating more. It can really save on unnecessary abstaining later on.
  • The first temp shift can be rather weak so don’t hesitate to keep your instructor on speed dial for any questions you need clarity on.
  • It’s normal for cycles to be prolonged pre-ovulation and shorter then normal post-ovulation for as many as 6 or so cycles once cycling does return.
  • Working with your instructor is really important. For some methods the rules available to you can change depending on your fertility category. For instance with Northwest Family Services (NWFS,) there is a slightly different mucus patch type rule available for women who are in the first 12 weeks with “intensive breastfeeding” vs after that point and breastfeeding. Regardless it’s a good time to stay in close contact with someone trained if at all possible.

Lactational Amenorrhea Method (LAM)

The following information about LAM comes from Breastfeeding Answers Made Simple (Mohrbacher) pgs. 495-498

Lactational Amenorrhea Method (LAM) is a temporary NFP method that does not require abstinence and has been found to be at least 98% reliable during the first 6 months postpartum in studies around the world. LAM consists of breastfeeding rhythms that provide more that a prolonged period of natural infertility.

For LAM to be effective, the mother must answer “NO” to three specific questions:

1. Have your menses returned? (Menses defined as two consecutive days of bleeding after 8 weeks postpartum or a vaginal bleed the mother considers a menses.)

2. Are you supplementing (with formula or via bottle) regularly or allowing long periods without breastfeeding either day or night?

3. Is your baby more than 6 months old?

When a mother can answer NO to all three questions, she has less than a 2% chance of pregnancy. When a mother’s answer is YES to any of the three questions, she should begin using another method of family planning.

The key to suppression of fertility through breastfeeding is frequent breastfeeding, day and night. The mother can rely on LAM with confidence when she breastfeeds exclusively (Baby receives only mother’s milk and no other liquids or solids,) or almost exclusively (along with breastfeeding, baby receives no more than two mouthfuls daily of other foods, drinks, and/or vitamins/minerals,) at least until her menses return, her breastfeeding pattern changes, or her baby turns 6 months old.

LAM was originally limited to 6 months because this is when introduction of other foods is recommended. But if a mother’s menses has not returned, solids are given after the baby breastfeeds (or delayed past 6 months), and the mother does not go without breastfeeding for longer than 4 hours during the day and 6 hours at night, very few pregnancies occur.

Personally, my menses returned with DD1 at around 4 months postpartum, whereas with DD2, my menses was delayed until she was closer to 14 months. Both girls were exclusively breastfed, and solids were delayed until closer to 10 months with both girls. The big difference between the two girls was the frequency of night nursing. We didn’t start bedsharing until having DD2, and she literally nursed all night long. She would attach and stay attached.

 

Your turn! What has your experience been with LAM or postpartum charting? Do you switch from one method to another when breastfeeding or postpartum?

Thank You to Mikayla and Kristin for the postpartum charting info!!

______________________________________________________________

Tomorrow is our last day! We’ll talk about some non-religious reasons to switch to NFP/FAM!

 

Post to Twitter

What exactly does Health Care entail?

It would seem that my FaceBook feed has become noticeably more polarizing in the last few days. Mostly because I have friends all over the political spectrum and all are just as vocal as I am.

Over the last day or so, I have seen a photo pop up a few times:

There’s only one little problem with this… it would appear that it was never said by the President. The only info I can find on this particular quote is from postings and repostings on Tumblr. According to ONE link, the quote was made by a poster (Anneutral)* on a forum in response to Rick Santorum’s opinion on Women’s Health.

So…

What exactly is Women’s Health? Obviously, it depends greatly on whom you ask. In my opinion, Women’s Heath is taking care of the organs of the female, making sure they are functioning properly. To me, Women’s Health is caring for the well-being of the breast, cervix, Uterus, Ovaries, and Fallopian Tubes. It is not about pregnancy prevention or about fertility suppression.

To another, Women’s Heath does encompass pregnancy prevention (by any means, including hormonal and non-hormonal birth control and sterilization) along with the care of the organs of the woman. For this person, hormonal birth control does more than prevent ovulation and therefore pregnancy, but it also treats the painful symptoms of endometriosis and PCOS. (Treats the symptoms, but is not a cure, mind you.)

Still another may wonder why we need a separate designation for WOMEN’S health care. After all, if women want to be treated and equal to men, shouldn’t this argument just be about… Health Care? Why should Women’s Health Care be more special or important than the Care of Men or Children?

All of that brings us to the question: What is Health Care?

The prevention, treatment, and management of illness and the preservation of mental and physical well-being through the services offered by the medical and allied health professions

The Health Care debate, like all other debates in modern culture, is rife with opinions, points and counter-points and we are all caught in the middle with nowhere to go.

______________________________________________________________

You have thoughts! Share them!

Don’t forget to enter into my latest Giveaway! The Giveaway is open to U.S. Residents only (sorry!) and will remain open until midnight (PST) June 30 (THAT’S TODAY!!) The winner will be contacted within 48 hours of the giveaway end and will have 48 hours to reply before a new winner is chosen!

*And it would appear that “Anneutral got it from another picture of Obama saying the quote. The Source of the Quote is still Unknown. See comment #51 and #52

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Post to Twitter